StoreFab logoSTOREFAB
Built by a fabricator. Tuned for sellers.

How StoreFab grading works

A grade you can't check is just a number somebody made up. So here is the whole method — what we measure, how the letter is worked out, what we never score, and where the facts behind a fix come from. If this page and your report ever disagree, the report is wrong and we want to hear about it.

Where this came from

StoreFab was built and proven on the founder's own store first — more than 8,000 live listings, graded and re-graded while thousands of fixes ran against it. Every one of those changes was re-read from eBay after it ran to prove it landed, and zero listings were damaged. Only when the system held up on a real store at real scale did it open to anyone else's. The founder's store is still the first store graded by every version of the grader.

What we measure

An audit reads your own live eBay store data — your inventory items, your listings, your ship-from places, and the settings you've picked in StoreFab — plus your listing traffic from eBay's analytics. Seven checks run over it:

  • Specifics — every item should carry the specifics for its kind of card (for Pokémon cards, that's the Card Number and the Set). An item counts as needing a fix when any of those details are blank — buyers filter searches on them, so a blank is a listing that's harder to find.
  • Titles — a title has to exist and fit eBay's limit of 80 characters. An empty title, or one that runs past the limit, counts as needing a fix.
  • Weight — every item needs a package weight above zero, or eBay can't work out shipping. A missing or zero weight counts as needing a fix.
  • Location — every published listing should sit on the one ship-from place you picked. A listing sitting anywhere else counts as needing a fix.
  • Best Offer — Best Offer should be on, with the lowest price you'll take at or above the target you set. A listing with Best Offer switched off, or a lowest price below your target, counts as needing a fix.
  • Category fit — every card should be filed under its own family — sports cards with the sports cards, game cards with the game cards. A card filed under the wrong family never shows up when buyers filter by sport or game, so it counts as needing a fix.
  • Unlisted cards — cards that aren't live, so no buyer can buy them, in three kinds: built but never put up for sale, no listing built yet, or went up for sale but the listing behind it isn't live anymore.

Two of the checks only score when you've switched them on. Location doesn't score until you pick the location every listing should sit on, and the Best Offer lowest-price check doesn't score until you set a target — until then they show on your report as information, and they're left out of the math entirely.

How the grade is worked out

Each scored check gets its own letter from the share of listings that need a fix: 1% or fewer needing one is an A, up to 3% a B, up to 6% a C, up to 12% a D, and more than that an F.

The score starts at 100, and each check takes points away in proportion to how much of the store needs a fix and how much that check counts. Specifics counts the most (30 of 100), then Titles (20), Location (15), Best Offer (15), Category fit (15), Weight (10) and Unlisted cards (10). When some checks aren't scoring, their share is spread across the ones that are. A score of 90 or more is an A, 80 a B, 70 a C, 60 a D, and below that an F.

Then the cap: your final grade can never sit more than one letter above your weakest scored check. One weak check holds the letter down on purpose, so a high score can't hide a real problem. Your report names the weakest check whenever the cap is what set your letter.

Sometimes eBay doesn't hand over your listings — a partial read. Then only Specifics, Titles and Weight can score, and the grade is printed as PARTIAL, on the report and on the certificate, so nobody mistakes it for the full picture. And if we can't read any of your inventory items at all, there is no grade: we say what we can see instead of inventing a letter.

Traffic is handled the same honest way. Dead stock (below) is counted only from listings eBay's analytics actually measured, over the trailing 90 days. Your report always says "measured X of Y" — a listing that wasn't measured is never treated as if it had zero views.

What we never score

Dead stock. Listings with zero views in the trailing 90 days are reported, because the number is useful — but they are never scored. Slow listings don't hurt your grade.

Your prices. StoreFab does not grade what you charge. Your prices are not an input to any check. The one place a price appears at all is inside the Best Offer check, where the lowest price you set is compared against the target percentage you set, worked out from your own list price. That grades whether your lowest price matches your number — never whether your price is right.

Where the card facts come from

When the Specifics fix proposes a value for a blank detail, the value comes from a shared card-facts layer: what sellers' own listings say about the same card. A card is identified by its public facets — game, set, card name, card number, language, variant and year. The layer never holds anything about a seller's store: no prices, no quantities, no conditions, and no seller names — contributions are stored under a scrambled seller code, never an identity.

The trust rules are strict, because a wrong fact written into somebody's listing is worse than a blank:

And even a trusted fact is only ever proposed: it appears in a plan, with the exact listings and the exact values, and nothing is written until you approve that plan.

Proof, not promises

StoreFab is not affiliated with eBay, and eBay has not endorsed StoreFab or its grades. The grade is our measurement — published with its method, so you can check the working yourself.

Get your free grade